How Do I Know If I Need a Hip Replacement?
Hip pain that wakes you at night, a stiff hip that makes socks and shoes a struggle, a limp that has crept in: these are common reasons people start to ask whether they need a hip replacement. The decision is yours and it is rarely urgent, but there are clear signs that it is time to talk to a surgeon.
When is a hip replacement considered?
A hip replacement is usually for hip osteoarthritis, where the cartilage that cushions the ball and socket has worn away. Other reasons include rheumatoid arthritis, avascular necrosis (when the ball of the hip loses its blood supply and collapses), and arthritis after an old injury or hip dysplasia. It is a planned operation. Most people try other treatments first, and the decision rests on how much the hip affects your life, not on age or X-rays alone.
5 signs surgeons look for
1. Pain that limits everyday life
Hip arthritis pain is usually felt in the groin, the front of the thigh or the buttock, and sometimes down to the knee. It is time to talk to a surgeon when it gets in the way of:
- Walking more than a short distance
- Climbing stairs or getting up from a chair
- Getting in and out of a car
- Putting on shoes and socks, or cutting your toenails
2. Pain at night or at rest
Early arthritis hurts mainly with activity. Pain that wakes you at night, or aches while you sit or lie still, is a sign that the joint is badly worn.
3. Stiffness and a limp
A worn hip slowly loses movement, especially turning the leg inwards. You may start to limp, need a walking stick, or feel that one leg has become shorter.
4. Other treatments no longer help
When exercise, physiotherapy, painkillers and an injection have been tried and no longer give enough relief, it is reasonable to discuss surgery.
5. X-rays show advanced damage
An X-ray may show the joint space has narrowed to bone on bone, with bony spurs around the joint. X-rays alone do not decide, though: some people with a badly worn hip on X-ray cope well, and the decision is guided by your symptoms.
Not sure if your hip is ready?
Our orthopaedic surgeons can assess your hip, with X-ray on site, and talk you through every option, including treatments that avoid surgery.
What to try first
- Exercise and physiotherapy: strengthening the muscles around the hip eases pain and keeps you moving
- Weight control: losing even a few kilograms reduces the load on the hip
- Pain relief: paracetamol or anti-inflammatory medicine, as advised by your doctor
- A walking stick: held in the hand opposite the painful hip, it takes weight off the joint
- A steroid injection: given into the hip under imaging guidance, it can ease pain for weeks to a few months
In younger hips with little arthritis, pain may come from a labral tear or hip impingement, which can sometimes be treated with keyhole surgery instead.
Is it safe to wait?
For most people, yes. Hip arthritis is not dangerous, and you can choose the timing. But if pain stops you moving, the muscles around the hip weaken and the hip stiffens further, which can make recovery after surgery slower. Avascular necrosis is the exception: the ball of the hip can collapse quickly, so have it checked promptly.
What to expect at your assessment
Your doctor asks how the hip affects your daily life, checks how you walk, how far the hip moves and your leg lengths, and reviews an X-ray of your pelvis and hips. An MRI is sometimes needed, for example to look for avascular necrosis or a labral tear.
If surgery is right for you, the options include a total hip replacement, robotic anterior hip replacement and, for some younger and active patients, hip resurfacing. With our enhanced recovery programme, most patients walk on the day of surgery and go home after 1 to 2 nights. Hip replacement at SSOC is led by Dr. Kelvin Tan Guoping.
Related reading
FAQ
Will hip arthritis always lead to a hip replacement?
No. Many people with hip arthritis manage well for years with exercise, weight control, a walking stick and pain relief. A hip replacement is only considered when the hip limits your life despite these treatments.
Am I too young or too old for a hip replacement?
There is no strict age limit. Most people are between 50 and 80, but younger people with a badly damaged hip can benefit, and fit people in their 80s and 90s do well too. Your general health matters more than your age.
What if both of my hips are painful?
Both hips can sometimes be replaced in one operation in selected patients. More often they are done a few months apart, starting with the worse side. Your surgeon will advise what suits you.


